New Harbinger Publications Inc. Logo
Off the Couch - The Latest in Psychology and Mental Health

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Monday, November 16, 2009
it's not 'my mind' - it's me!

:: 9 Comments :: Article Rating :: ACT Made Simple
 

One of the simplest ways to create a context of defusion is to talk about ‘the mind’ in session as if it’s a separate entity. For example, we might say things like:

  • "So what’s your mind doing now?"
  • "Notice what your mind has to say about that"
  • "So when your mind wants to get you all worked up about this, what kind of things does it say to you?"
  • "If I could listen in to your mind when it’s beating you up, what kind of things would I hear it saying?"
  • "So your mind says “There’s no hope. It’s a waste of time. This therapy won’t work”. Shall we stop the session just because that’s what your mind says – or shall we let your mind say that and carry on?"
  • "And what happens if you let your mind bully you around, tell you what to do?"
  • "What’s your mind saying to you right now?"

 

This way of talking about ‘the mind’ helps to create awareness of and detachment from thoughts, and we can even be more explicit. For example, we can use the metaphor (from Hayes et al, 1999) of "Four People in the Room":

Therapist: It’s often helpful to talk as if there’s four of us in the room; you and me, and your mind and my mind. Your mind’s going to tell you stuff, and my mind’s going to tell me stuff, and what’s most important in this room is how you and I work together, and not so much what our minds have to say.

While many clients respond well to this way of talking in session, from time to time someone objects. They may say, "It’s not 'my mind' – it’s me!’

One simple response is this:
Therapist: "Okay, so the part of you that walks and runs and dances – what do you call that?"
Client: "My legs"
Therapist: "And the part of you that writes and types and holds things – what do you call that?"
Client: "My hands"
Therapist: "And the part of you that talks and sings and eats – what do you call that?"
Client: "My mouth"
Therapist: "And the part of you that thinks – what do you call that?"
Client: (pause) ‘My mind"
Therapist: "So that’s what I’m talking about. When I use the word mind, I mean the part of you that thinks. (pause) So what’s your mind telling you right now?"

Some clients may still not go along with this convention. For example, in answer to the above question you may get this response:
Client: "It’s not my mind; it’s me."
Therapist: "Yes, it is a very important part of you. And clearly it’s not the whole of you. Your hands are a part of you, and your legs are a part of you, and your mouth is a part of you, and so on. And I think it’s very important that we have some word for this part of you that we can agree on – because obviously there’s a lot more to you than just your mind. So if we don’t use the word ‘mind’ to describe the part of you that thinks, what word can we use instead?"
Client: "It’s my brain"
Therapist: "Okay. I’m happy to go with that. So we’ll call it your brain. So what’s your brain telling you right now?"

As therapists and coaches we need to be flexible in our language, and adapt it to suit our clients. It feels a bit odd if I have to use the word ‘brain’ instead of the word ‘mind’, but if it helps facilitate defusion and prevent struggles with the client, I’m more than happy to do so.


Posted By newharb / 12:00 AM / Monday, November 16, 2009
Comments
comment By Marco @ Wednesday, November 18, 2009 12:46 AM
Congrats with your blog!!

Grtz
-M.

comment By lou shepherd @ Wednesday, November 18, 2009 6:40 PM
really nice and simple suggestions as per usual! thanks Russ. The book looks great!

comment By Chel Bardell @ Wednesday, November 18, 2009 7:40 PM
This is exactly the type of nitty-gritty stuff that is so useful to discuss - thanks, Russ! Can't wait to read the new book.

comment By Patricia Durning @ Wednesday, November 18, 2009 7:41 PM
Nice to see sample conversations, particularly where the client always being co-operative. Very useful. Thanks.

comment By Marco @ Thursday, November 19, 2009 1:09 AM
On using the word 'brain': IMHO it may be helpful to use 'brain' because by doinig that you can refer to a body part that functions as it's supposed to (it creates thoughts), but with a tendency to make itself a little more important than necessary... You can't to that with 'mind'.
But after all, it's a matter of taste I guess..

Best,
Marco

comment By Matthew Bastin @ Thursday, November 19, 2009 3:48 AM
I would like to congratulate Russell on his new book although the price is about 2x what I would be prepared to pay. I am very happy that this blog gives me the opportunity to convey and share my thoughts. (Keep in mind, thinking is not a dirty word). I have almost finished reading and studying "The Happiness Trap" and have gained a great deal of benefit from it I look forward to more. I will hopefully also read in full "ACT made simple". Are the there any comments about about an imminent workshop for merely interested people on ACT, Russell?

comment By Gill @ Friday, November 20, 2009 12:45 AM
This blog has turned up right on cue for me. It's going to be really helpful. Thanks

comment By Eric Nicholson @ Friday, November 20, 2009 9:23 AM
I am finding ACT quite helpfull. Do you know that it has parallels with Eckhart Tolle's The Power of Now? The mindfullness aspect is very refreshing to see in the psychotherapeutic context.
I also wonder how much help personal therapy would be with a professional? I know finding one who knows about ACT is a bit of a lottery!

comment By Ruby Karmay @ Saturday, November 21, 2009 6:23 PM
Instead of using the word mind for thoughts but label it my "thinking part". To label it as it is would create less confusion. Your point! In my definition of mind which is 'that which is clear and knowing' and has a sense of self or continuity associated with it too, thoughts and emotions mental images come in and out of it. It is very interesting to examine. Thank you

Click here to post a comment
Print  

related books

Transforming Depression Depression 101 Mindful Path through Worry and Rumination Connecting the Dots MBSR Workbook
Bookmark and Share
Subscribe
Print  

a blog by Russ Harris, MD

Print  
NH Authors on Huffington Post Syndicate  
NH Authors on Psychology Today

 
Barton Goldsmith, Ph.D.

 
Cassandra Vieten, Ph.D.

 
Jefferson Singer, Ph.D.

 
John P. Forsyth, Ph.D.

 
Karen Leland

 
Kelly McGonigal, Ph.D.

 
Marilyn Krieger, Ph.D.

 
Mary Lamia, Ph.D.


Rick Hanson, Ph.D.


Russ Federman, Ph.D., ABPP

 
Russ Harris, MD

 
Stephanie Sarkis, Ph.D.

 
Steven C. Hayes, Ph.D.


Susan Albers, Psy.D.

 
Susan Pease Gadoua

 
Troy DuFrene



NH Authors on Psych Central

  Elisha Goldstein, Ph.D.

  Pavel Somov, Ph.D.

  Suzanne Phillips, Psy.D., ABPP

  Dianne Kane, DSW

NH Authors on You Tube

  Barton Goldsmith, Ph.D.

   Jeff Wood, Psy.D.

   Patty James, MS

  Susan Albers, Psy.D.

  Ronald Alexander, Ph.D.

  MBSR Workbook

Print